Skip to main content

For sale · Detached · 2 1/2 Storey

458 Markham Street.

Palmerston-Little Italy, Toronto, ON M6G 2L2

On the market128 days
MLS® C13479674Courtesy of Re/max Hallmark Realty Ltd.
Bedrooms5
Bathrooms6
Lot24 x 125 ftFrontage by depth, as listed
Parking4None

Balanced market

House market in Palmerston-Little Italy. Sales and new listings are roughly in step, so neither side has a clear edge. Homes here sell in about 20 days. Market data

Sales-to-new-listings ratio, last 3 months: 48%
Months of supply: 4.2

What it means

  • Balanced market in Palmerston-Little Italy: houses take about 20 days to sell.
  • About 4.2 months of houses for sale in Palmerston-Little Italy at the current pace of sales.

At a glance

Property taxes$18,890 / year
BasementSeparate Entrance
Approximate age100+ years
Size3,500–5,000 sq ft

About this home

Professionals or Investors, this grand beauty has been very well maintained and it represents a time of design and construction not seen in generations. There are currently 4 units plus an unoccupied professional dental office which has an entrance on Harbord Street with great exposure and is approximately 1,400 sq. ft. . Located in the heart of the Annex, you are right along Harbord Street at Markham and only steps to Bathurst, Bloor street nd the subway. This is a perfect live/work space or investment opportunity. Over 4,200 square feet, the building was extensively renovated in 1990 and the roof was fully replaced 2 years ago. There is parking at the rear with easy access off Harbord St. This bustling neighbourhood attracts people who want a beautiful downtown area with character, architecturally beautiful homes from the early 1900's and super convenient access to downtown, U of T and hospital row. Currently there are 2-two bedroom units, 1-one bedroom unit and a bachelor unit. Three of the units have their own balconies. The basement is a high and very dry basement with a seperate entrance, storage and a laundry area for the dental clinic. Plans currently exist to convert the dental office into 2 more residential units.

Home details

Click the + to read more.

The homeproperty type, style, size, heating
Property type
Detached
Style
2 1/2 Storey
Size
3,500–5,000 sq ft
Heating
Radiant
Cooling
Other
Basement
Separate Entrance
Year built
100+
Lot size
24 × 125 feet
Possession
July 31, 2026
Parking and storageparking, garage
Parking
4
Garage
None
Fees and taxesproperty taxes, price per sq ft
Property taxes
$18,890 (2026)
Price per sq ft
$800
What is includedAppliances and fixtures

All existing appliances and chattels belonging to the Seller. (4 fridges, 4 stoves, 4 washers, 4 dryers, 2 wall a/c uits)

What it could cost each month

— a month, estimated

With 20% down. Includes property tax. Estimate only.

Change the numbersHide the calculator
  • Mortgage—
  • Property tax—

Down payment —. Estimate only, using Canadian semi-annual compounding; your lender's numbers will differ.

How this price compares

Members

7 similar detached houses sold in Palmerston-Little Italy in the last 12 months.

Sales activity nearby

Number of similar detached houses sold each quarter.

0Jan–Mar20250Apr–Jun20250Jul–Sep20250Oct–Dec20251 sold, Jan to Mar 20261Jan–Mar20262 sold, Apr to Jun 20262Apr–Jun20263 sold, Jul to Sep 20263Jul–Sep20261 sold, Oct to Dec 20261Oct–Dec2026 so far

See what similar houses sold for

A free account shows sold prices nearby, full history and alerts for homes like this.

Create a free account

Already a member? Sign in

Own a home in Palmerston-Little Italy?

See what yours could sell for, based on recent sales nearby.

Get your home’s value

See what homes in Palmerston-Little Italy sold for

Sold prices, price history and how this price compares are free with an account. It takes a minute, and you can save homes and get alerts too.

Create a free account

Sale and listing history

Past sales at this address are for members

A free account shows past sale prices and dates, sold prices nearby, and alerts when similar homes list.

Sign in to view

The area

Listing brokerage · MLS® C13479674Re/max Hallmark Realty Ltd.Data last updated Sep 13, 2026 7:02 pm.

The listing data is provided under copyright by the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB). The information provided herein is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by TRREB or its members. It is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA. Used under licence.

Want to see it in person?

Tell us when suits you and our team will set up a private showing.

$3,400,0005 bed · 6 bathBook a showing